Don’t Blame the Unemployed For High Taxes


I got this absurd cartoon emailed to me the other day and I thought I should reply to it.  A couple people that I know are conservatives and they run around with the rallying cry that “people who work” pay exorbitant taxes because there is a huge portion of the population that “doesn’t work” and just slides by.  Any time you actually throw some numbers at these people, they just deny them because they’re happy about the fact that they can be pissed off and hate certain groups and they frankly don’t want you raining on their parade.

But seriously folks, bitching about your taxes is like bitching about the fact that you’re going to die.  Any time you start thinking that you’re being asked to lift up an unfair percentage of the burden, it’s just because you’re not thinking of all the ways you are treated fairly (and probably more than fairly in most cases).
Fact number ONE: the employment rate is right around 90% and of the 10% that are unemployed, 5% would chose to be unemployed regardless.  As I was preparing to write this article, I actually did some research (gasp…another thing these emotional idiots never do) and found on this web page that the yearly amount spent on unemployment is around 200 billion dollars.  Now, that might seem like a lot, but when you take into account that the budget is 3.5 trillion dollars and that unemployment only accounts for around 5% of that, the number seems pretty reasonable to me.
Actually, it’s not all that easy to find good break downs of the US budget.  But I did find on wikipedia that the biggest two expenses are defense (800 billion) and medicare (700 billion).  However I suppose putting in, “so you can be a tax slave for people who want to keep their grandparents alive” isn’t quite funny enough for the above “hilarious” joke (even if it is more true).
The ironic thing about this comic is that the guy I got it from is himself a government employee.  Now, when I was looking at that 200 billion dollar unemployment budget, I couldn’t help but wonder how much of that went to government officials who decided who the money went to (talk about a redundant occupation).  What do you think it is?  25 billion, 50 billion?  My point is that in every break down of this whole thing, the biggest amount of your tax dollars go to people who are WORKING FOR THE GOVERNMENT!
And isn’t it the case that conservatives always say we should make the government smaller?  Isn’t it then super hypocritical for ANYONE who claims to be conservative to be working in the government?
In the case of the guy who sent me this comic, I remember when he got his “cushy government job” as he called it.  He bragged about how he would never work in the private sector again because in government he got paid more for doing less (just think of every road crew you’ve ever seen, there is always one guy working a shovel and three guys standing around).
So I got inspired and sent him the following response:
As you can probably guess, instead of recognizing the hypocrisy in his position and even making an attempt at acknowledging it or defending it, he decided instead to find fault with the fact that my wife and I found a social service program to help pay the cost of our baby’s delivery.  That argument was just downright idiotic for the following reasons:
1.  I’ve never been against social programs (I think they’re a good thing).
2.  There is a MAJOR difference between what hospitals charge and what insurance companies actually pay (for example if your insurance tells you you’re getting a $50 medication for $5 thanks to them, implying that the insurance company pays $45, the truth of the matter is that the insurance company pays nothing…heck, they might even get some money back from the pharmaceutical company for maintaining the illusion of value).
3.  A one time 5-10K payment for a birth DOES NOT COMPARE to a yearly payment of 60-80K (I don’t know how much he makes) that is ongoing!
4.  Don’t bring my wife and baby into it motherfucker!
Look, taxes aren’t high because “some people don’t work” taxes are high because you’re making too much money.  Instead of bitching about it like an impudent dipshit, you should do what all the other rich people do, HIDE YOUR INCOME, make huge tax-deductible donations to your kids, establish tax-exempt corporations, take advantage of social programs.  Running around pissed off in the sense that “things should be different” is just infantile.  After all, there’s an old axiom that goes like this:
The immature man berates the fact that things aren’t as they should be, the mature man takes advantage of the way things are.
(if that’s not an axiom it should be).
Oh, and one final little jab to all you conservatives.  Screaming for a tax-cut is the same as asking for a government hand-out.  Just shut up, nobody has any sympathy for people who can’t afford to pay for their third house.  When you’ve had the courage to travel the world and see real poverty (mainly with people who work 80 hours a week) you’ll see just how abhorrent that attitude is.

Subscribe to “Streets of Lima” by Email

Previous Learning Modalities Don't Exist (It's Not Science Folks)
Next Peruvian Car Security

11 Comments

  1. Anonymous
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    How can "throw him under the bus" guy says that your article is not classy? Not classy is getting your wife and daughter involve in your arguments, that is low, very low. The worst part is that I liked him. Sad ending!!!

  2. 09/27/2016
    Reply

    I offered this guy more than sufficient face to face time to know he wasn't being reasonable. When a person fails to adhere to the courtesy of civilized discussion, they're just trying to bully you or muscle you rather than explore your logic. The only reason people refuse to acknowledge your cold hard facts is because they know they can't refute them. If they persist in ridiculing you and ignoring your side of the discussion all for the purpose of presenting their beliefs as indisputable dogma, you actually run the risk of damaging yourself if you continue to engage in civilized tactics. Therefore if your only choices are to throw their underhanded tactics back at them or retreat to the safety of a public forum, your only option is to chose the later (for the sake of avoiding your personal corruption…no doctrine of courtesy ever would warrant any other option).

  3. Throw him under the bus
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    I'm not saying don't say anything to the guy but do it face to face, not on the internet, which is an open forum to the world, and, more-or-less permanent.

    It's fine to disagree with the guy, but it's the forum your using. That's all I'm saying.

  4. 09/27/2016
    Reply

    I agree that it's depressing, but I don't agree that it lacks class. After all, I didn't mention the guy's name, I just put his ridiculous argument out there.

    Something had to be done and this is what I did. I'm sure the end result will be just as bad for me as everyone else involved, but things weren't going to be allowed to proceed as they had been going.

    Honestly, the guy's simply in the wrong. When I see somebody in the wrong, I say so. I'm not a silent enabler like 99% of the world. Being outspoken costs me, but in the end it's best if you stand by your principles. I learned that a long time ago.

  5. Throw him under the bus
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    Fine–cease communication, that's cool, but don't embarrass him on the internet. That's just…depressing. The internet is permanent, and there's no privacy. You could've been classy about it.

  6. 09/27/2016
    Reply

    Hello Gls,
    Yes, I see your point and I need to work on the wording. How about if I put it this way, "it's more productive to work the system with the goal of changing it from the inside, than it is to engage in outright rebellion."
    Thanks for the comment!

  7. gls5000
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    "The immature man berates the fact that things aren't as they should be, the mature man takes advantage of the way things are."

    I don't think immature and mature are the right words there, when you think that a) if nobody complained about the way things are, nothing would ever improve, and b) an example of people who take advantage of the way things are, are corrupt government officials and criminals.

    Interesting article though.

  8. 09/27/2016
    Reply

    I like this post Ben! You make some excellent points.

    YES government is quite inefficient
    YES it seems that we pay a lot in taxes
    YES all of the services that the government provides citizens are taken for granted

    NO bitching isn't likely to help

    WHAT TO DO: Get smart and work the system (it was designed for you to do so)

  9. Anonymous
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    Wow! Way to through your friend under the bus in this article. I'm glad you're using an open forum on the internet to argue against this guy. Don't be surprised if he doesn't talk to you for awhile.

  10. 09/27/2016
    Reply

    Hey Hines,
    Yeah, I was a little pissed off when I wrote this. My main point was just the conservative notion that we should reduce government. I think the US government is out of control, and if it was cut in half, the tax problem would probably solve itself. I'm looking at this from a cause rather than symptom viewpoint.

    http://www.allinperu.com/

  11. Lucho
    09/27/2016
    Reply

    A friend of mine who joins every anti-Obama, anti-Democrat, pro-Republican, pro-Tea Party group on Facebook recently announced to her friends: (spouse's name) just got a job with the state government….after all these years. Great benefits! Yeah!
    Also in a conversation in a Boy Scouts meeting with a Republican, Tea Party parent, he was very enthusiastic with me agreeing that the budget was out of control and that spending and taxes should be reduced. He did not like me saying, however, that the US spent as much on defense as the rest of the world and that the US navy was as large as the next 15 navies combined, all of which except two (China's and Russia's) belonged to US allies (data can easily be confirmed on line)and that we should reduce the US budget at least 20 percent.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *